第17回
原子力発電所の司法リスクを下げる対策の提案
著者:
田中 治邦,(日本原燃),堀池 寛,(大阪大),宮野 廣,(元法政大),鈴木 孝寛,(保全学会)
発刊日:
公開日:
キーワードタグ:
Many lawsuits against civil nuclear power facilities have been brought after the severe core damage accident occurred at Fukushima Daiichi NPS. Especially, requests for provisional disposition order to prohibit operation of one nuclear power reactor has been filed to more than one district court by different plaintiffs including those who live far away from the reactor site. Measures are studied in order to avoid losing lawsuits against nuclear power plant licensed through rigorous NRA review with upgraded ...
英字タイトル:
Study of Measures to Reduce Risk of Lawsuits for Nuclear Power Plants
第17回
大飯原発行政訴訟の論点
著者:
堀池 寛,(大阪大),宮野 廣,(元法政大),蛯沢 勝三,(保全学会),高田 毅士,(JAEA)
発刊日:
公開日:
キーワードタグ:
The trial case against operation of OOI nuclear power plant is studied from the view point of nuclear science and engineering. This case the negative judgements was decided, whose judgement is found to base on the bench’s logical at very superficial constitution, which lacked a consideration for statistical data analysis....
英字タイトル:
A study on the trial case about OOI NPP
第17回
損害賠償裁判にみる国の責任~バックフィット制度の位置づけと 長期予測の信頼性に関する司法判断~
著者:
堀池 寛,(大阪大),鈴木 孝寛,(保全学会),田中 治邦,(日本原燃),宮野 廣,(元法政大)
発刊日:
公開日:
キーワードタグ:
福島第一事故をめぐる裁判の中で、国の(損害賠償)責任を追及する事例がある。そこでの主要 な論点は次の三つである。①国に規制権限があったのか(バックフィット制度の有無、およびそ の対象)、②規制権限を行使する前提として H14 年長期評価は十分に信頼性のあるものであったのか、③規制権限を行使しなかったことに過失等はなかったのか。多くの裁判所は、前記の三論 点について国の責任を認めている。...
英字タイトル:
State Responsibility concerning 1F Accident
第17回
科学的合理性と工学の判断 -リスク情報を活用した意思決定
著者:
高田 毅士,(JAEA),堀池 寛,(大阪大),宮野 廣,(元法政大),蛯沢 勝三,(保全学会)
発刊日:
公開日:
キーワードタグ:
This paper covers the recent decisions made by Osaka and Saga district courts, respectively, for Nos. 3 and 4 reactors at the Ohi NPP and Nos. 3 and 4 reactors at the Genkai NPP, and discusses the disputed points in determination of design basis ground motions to be used for seismic safety checking, which are regulated in Nuclear Regulatory Authority (NRA) review guide. In the paper, the points in these decisions are clarified and the authors’ view regarding those points are presented, and finally the sugge...
英字タイトル:
Scientific Rationality and Engineering Decision Towards Risk-informed Decision Making
第17回
行政訴訟と民事訴訟
著者:
堀池 寛,(大阪大),鈴木 孝寛,(保全学会),田中 治邦,(日本原燃),宮野 廣,(元法政大)
発刊日:
公開日:
キーワードタグ:
Trial cases against operation of nuclear power plants are studied from the view point of nuclear science and engineering. At present both administrative litigations and civil litigations are allowed to take place in Japan, where the latter method is mainly aims to relieve cases of immature legal regulation. Problems of civil litigation in the nuclear reactor regulation of very well adjusted and established....
英字タイトル:
Administrative Litigation and Civil Litigation
第17回
規制の耐震基準判断の論点 -新規制基準における耐震関連基準類の改善の提案-
著者:
蛯沢 勝三,(保全学会),堀池 寛,(大阪大),宮野 廣,(元法政大),高田 毅士,(JAEA)
発刊日:
公開日:
キーワードタグ:
The authors analyzed the outlines of the OOI NPP judgment and the Nuclear Regulation Authority's (NRA’s) explanation materials on the judgment. In addition, the outline of the related guidelines of the NRA related to both was also analyzed. Based on these analysis results, the authors identified six issues, and analyzed and examined them. We proposed improvement to the guidelines. The five issues are as follows; handling of uncertainty of seismic evaluation in NRA guides, specific examples of reflections of...
英字タイトル:
A study on the Trial Case about OOI NPP -Proposal for Improvement of Seismic-related Guidelines in New Regulatory Guide-
第17回
規制の耐震基準判断の論点 -原発の耐震における新規制基準-
著者:
宮野 廣,(元法政大),堀池 寛,(大阪大),蛯沢 勝三,(保全学会),高田 毅士,(JAEA)
発刊日:
公開日:
キーワードタグ:
We have been investigating the issues of the nuclear power plant suspension trial. Many of the recent issues are related to the validity of seismic assessments. Our study group has clarified what is the technical issue. and is working to show appropriate responses to technical issues that have not been explained in the trial. This report outlines the latest concept of seismic evaluation and clarifies the issues regarding the uncertainty of evaluation....
英字タイトル:
A study on the Trial Case about OOI NPP -New Regulatory Guide for Seismic Evaluation of Nuclear Power Plants-